Help Me Decide

Breaking news- I just checked the Pier 1 site and the prices have been reduced on all mirrored pieces in the Hayworth Collection- the prices listed below were the original prices.

Remember I told you about the new Pottery Barn mirrored side table I was so excited to find for my bedroom? Well, it is sold out in the NYC area stores and is back-ordered online. In the meantime, though, one reader reminded me that Pier 1's "Hayworth Collection" is similar (and less expensive). So, I checked it out in my local Pier 1 store.

Here is the store's signage displaying the entire Hayworth Collection and its prices . I would only be getting a small table, but you can go all-out if you want (though I think getting too many mirrored pieces like this may be overkill, unless you're Marie Antoinette):


The tall chest of drawers ($449.95) is another nice piece that would work well on its own to glam up any bedroom:


Here you can also see the large mirror (which I like for any room) as well as the coordinasting Queen headboard ($449). I wasn't so crazy about the headboard; I think an upholstered one would soften the overall look.


The smaller night-table is very cute and affordable at $199, but I don't think it has enough storage for me:


I would probably opt for the bedside chest instead ($399) since it's slightly larger and has more interior storage:


The Hayworth Collection bedside table is actually the same price ($399) as Pottery Barn's table (see below), but I am still having trouble deciding. Which one do you prefer? Give me your opinions in the comments. Here they are again:

Pottery Barn:


Pier 1 (also shown in photos above)


p.s. A number of you have asked me about what fabric Tori Spelling used for her fantastic upholstered headboard (which is flanked by two mirrored bedside tables). I am investigating this (I may even be meeting Tori next week!) and hope to have an answer for you soon! I am also going to present more options for upholstered headboards.